JamesYTP said:
Ya know, interestingly enough I'd heard early on a lot of people who were into Digimon saying they kinda hope they ignore 02, which was weird to me since as a kid at least I remember that being everyone's favorite series (aside from me of course, Tamers was always my fav personally). Does the general fandom frown on it now or something?
I kind of would disagree just a little with the idea that it being a film series posed much of a problem for it overall rather than a TV series though. Really they just needed to pace it a bit more evenly IMO since there were a few plot elements they don't really elaborate all that well. But all told I thought if anything that despite the truncated length the whole central conflict of Meicoomon being essentially the instrument of the end and the whole "will we really have to kill her thing" kind of lost it's punch a film or two short of the end to me. I thought they did a decent job of making you feel that tension there for quite a while and I felt bad for Mei in the end but by the last film it was like "if you're gonna do it just do it already!" lmao.
Kind of thought there was a lot of "edginess for edginess sake" kinda moments thrown in like that part where Gennai licks Sora or as I mentioned the giant naked Meicoomon fusion thing crashing down in like almost a doggie style position shot right from behind...wow. The EVA imagery looked cool but I agree it was like....WHY? Thematically they were going for something similar in the middle but this had little to do with it...it was a cool design I guess but whatevs.
I will say I dod appreciate the upped animation quality on the fights and stuff though, they were pretty fun to watch. Only better Digimon fights I can think of were the Hosoda directed ones from the first few movies.
I don't have the sources on me and what I'm going to say is completely speculation. In terms of success, Digimon Adventure 02 has the highest ratings among the Digimon series in Japan. On that aspect, it seems that they're commercially successful.
In the American Fandom, it's definitely frowned upon due to 1) replacing their favorite characters with essentially discount versions (the production behind Digimon Adventure 02 was horrid) and 2) it's fairly recent, as you said, that the fandom condemn Digimon Adventure 02 (it's similar to show Star Wars Prequel was praised by fans when they first released, but nowadays, if anyone mentions them, they're considered satan themselves).
Yeah, I agreed that had they had pace the film a bit more, it would be a much better experience (considering that all the films were completed in 2015, you would think reshoots would be in order). I argue that the TV series would force them to slow down, understand that certain elements simply did not need to be added in. For example, I completely hated the digimon subplots where they're going around looking for food: it's not that it's childlike or anything, but it came off as annoying when they're shoving it in your face "Hey guys, these little buggers are SO CUTE, LOOK'EM!"
Plus, it would probably be a lot better if they simply cut down the constant need to showcase everyone digivolving for the millionth time just to pad the movie even more.
Oh my god, the whole Gennai licking Sora was probably the most dumbest thing that came out of the film series. It's not even edgy, it was just out of place that it took me out of the film. Like you said, the Meicoomon battle could've been better, if not, outright amazing, but it wasn't. The military took the majority of the screen time; the rest of the gang basically didn't matter and it was once again, Tai and Matt doing the main meat of the work.
Hikari's statement to Taichi was also kind of confusing.
"I'll probably never forgive you [for killing Meicoomon], Taichi."
"That's why, I'm going to help you kill Meicoomon".
Like... what?
Plus, Hikari's reaction to Tai being alive was... jarring. I think you're on to something here... that there is a lot of edge for the sake of edge or melodrama. Hikari freak the hell out (I guess) when Tai died, but shown no reaction when Tai appeared. That's a big major issue in the movies: none of the character shown real human emotion, unless the plot shits on them for it: unless it involves crazy faces and a lunatic laugh.